Tag Archives: Peerless Peer

The Peerless Peer

29 Jul

In “The Peerless Peer” by Philip Jose Farmer, Sherlock Holmes and John Watson are sent to Africa in WWI on a mission for Mycroft Holmes to aid against the war against Germany. On the way they meet up with the villain from “His Last Bow” – Baron Von Bork, and assorted characters from popular culture & literature, including Lord Greystoke aka Tarzan, the ‘peerless peer’ of the book’s title.

The problem with the “Peerless Peer” for me was that it was impossible to tell whether I was reading pastiche or parody. I felt Holmes and Watson were caricatures, rather than interpretations of the the characters. Both felt horribly wrong to me.

The book was originally published in 1974, and reprinted in 2011 by Titan Books as part of their “Further Adventures of Sherlock Holmes” series. I rather feel this is one adventure that really didn’t need to be retold. I am sure people will disagree with me, and that is fine. Someone else reading the book may love it, and I really hope they do. It is just that for me, this book did not work.

I’m afraid I was deeply disappointed with this book.

%d bloggers like this: